I've told you about the contractual problems we've been having with White Light (translation: they are trying to steal our music for $1 -- copyright, publishing, everything). Finally, since they weren't rewriting their contract to reflect us owning our own music. . . I sent them one that I wrote. And I got this response:
Jason,
If you give us a license to use your music vs. "work for hire", I have to review with the board/investors and it will take time.
The 50% profit from sale of the sound track will be shared among the groups of musicians. So if only your group on the sound track... you'll get 50% profit from the sound tract. If two groups, you'll get 25% (do the simple math).
Did you have a song for the last scene? Any way we can listen to it?
Have you composed the "Preview" ?
Give me a call sometime today, I want to give you an LOI (Letter of Intent) before we can finalize the contract.
So then I send her a rough copy of the song. .. turns out we may not need to finalize that contract anyway, because she says this:
Jason,
The last scene is about the father lost his daughter. He missed the time they were together. In the process of rearing her he learned much more than he taugh her. He once gave her a life. Then he gave up her life to save him. And because of her he becomes a better person. He wishes he could be with his daughter again. Now she was gone, each time he looks up and sees a star, or a light he thinks of her. She is with him always.
Your song has no connection with the last scene!
Can you create a new song appropreate with the movie!
Wow!! And I actually did write the song after I read the entire script, knowing that scene exactly. When I asked for what specifically she thinks is inappropriate to the scene, she responds:
Jason,
Please write out the lyrics of your song and compare it with the description of the story.
Very terse. Very non-collaborative, in my opinion. In fact -- NO answer at all to my question.
Obviously, I think the song we wrote
is appropriate to the story -- I read the story and then wrote it. So I need to know from her what is not working in her opinion. That's why I asked for specifics.
For those of you that care, here are the words to the song:
but you've only just arrived, you've not yet even breathed the air
we had a whole lifetime to learn what we are
but now it's been cut down to only yesterday and the day before that
curse myself for taking any of you without gratitude
curse myself for not holding you yesterday
curse myself for not sharing who I am with you
and now I'm cursed to reach and not find you.
stay around, just for a little, at least to see that you were loved.
stay around, in the heavy air around me, let me hear your whispers
watch me cry the tears I should have spilled while you were here
stay around, just to hear the words I could never say
stay around, just to see the life we should have lived.
hey I hope we get another chance
to build what we weren't even able to start
hey I pray I'll see you again, in a world where I'm not so lost and clueless
hey look at me with sympathy, watch me never getting over you.
And here is a link to a rough version of it if you'd like to
hear it.
When I read the script, one of the more interesting things that emerged was that the father had a very hard time really connecting with his daughter, couldn't really get through to her and let her know how much he loved her. It was one of the more compelling things about the script, and the song does reflect on this a little. Maybe that isn't what she was going for? Who knows, because she won't tell me.
You know what, I like this song at this point. . . I wouldn't want to change it much for her. I like what it's become. Yes, it fits for the scene, but it's more than that too. I like the meaning that has emerged.
I asked her and asked her if she wanted anything specific for the song when she first asked us to write it and she just said, "Oh I heard your other stuff, I'm sure whatever you do will be fine." It's not like a wrote a song about the joy of chocolate milk or the pain of teenage acne. I wrote a song about the loss of a loved one that you didn't think you would lose, the realization that there was a deep well of love there and the regret that you'd never really shared it. And I even kept in a "after death" connection between the two per the script; you know, like when he sees the stars and thinks they are still together, like Ha mentions-- "look at me with sympathy, watch me never getting over you."
Even though I have my bouts with self-doubt and the like, I am a proud person with a good deal of self-confidence. That is to say, when I think I've done good work, I don't like it degraded. I do not appreciate the brusque way that Ha has addressed me here. It is not in the manner that I would treat someone who was helping me out -- for basically free.
I have a hard enough time hearing well thought out criticism, but I will hear that, because I know I should and I work hard to be able to accept it. But my goodness, her comments are showing no thought, they are not helpful. We're doing this for her for $1. So I am one millimeter away from telling Ha Le that this maybe is not a good fit after all and she should look for another band.
If this were actually a real Hollywood movie. . .or didn't seem so shady. . . or was a script that I absolutely loved. . .I would work harder to suck it up -- I can and will work through differences when the goal is worthy. I really make an effort to not be "difficult to work with," as many artists stereotypically are. . .But with this. . . I'm very tempted to just tell her to look elsewhere. But I need the approval of the rest of the band first -- it shouldn't be my decision to make alone.
Thoughts? And band. . . what do you think?